Skip to main content

How a College Football Video Game Could Work Today: A Proposal



Basic Premise

Operating under the assumption that the NCAA wants nothing to do with college video games as it stands, this game will be an unlicensed game. No real universities, players, conferences or stadiums will ship with the game. Instead the game will ship with fictional universities, stadiums and conferences. However, there will be incredibly robust customization options for teams, players, stadiums, uniforms, conferences, post-season, etc. These customization systems will allow for image files such as logos to be uploaded. Using these customization systems, users will be able to re-create real universities, their uniforms, their players, their stadiums, their conferences and more. Users will then be able to upload these re-created universities to file-share for all users to download for free. Considering the enormous community that currently updates the rosters for NCAA Football 2014, it’s certainly feasible that a sizable community would be eager & willing to essentially re-create the teams, stadiums & conferences that make up FBS football.

Utility Beyond FBS Football

A game like this does not have to end at re-creating FBS college football. Perhaps members of the community re-create the FCS ranks or Division 2 & 3 NCAA football. These are ranks that have obviously never been featured in a college football video game. Or perhaps you or someone in your local community creates your state’s high school teams. Maybe a 12-year-old wants to create his youth football teams and play with his teammates. Maybe you want to make up your own completely fictional college football universe. A setup like this is so ripe for fostering creativity and it would be a blast to see what the community would create.

Dynasty Mode

Very similar to dynasty mode as it stands on NCAA Football 2014. Players can play with the fictional teams that ship with the game, create their own team, or use the file share system to download all the current teams & conferences as created by the community. Players will be able to schedule non-conference games, play through seasons, manage their depth chart & recruit.

Players will also be able to set things such as the # of conference games you’d like to play, whether or not to play a conference championship game and re-arrange the conferences in the off-season.

Recruiting

There are 2 options for recruiting in Dynasty Mode:

1. For users who don’t like to recruit & want the feature to be as non-invasive as possible, a streamlined recruiting system similar to the one featured in NCAA Football 2014 can be used. Under this system, players simply have an allotted number of weekly points to spend on recruiting in-season. A higher number of points can be spent on higher priority targets or targets that need a little more swaying. Points can also be spent on scheduling official visits, scouting players, etc. How these points are managed is up to the user. Each prospect on your board will list their top schools and how much points that school has. You can re-adjust the point totals weekly when needed. For example, your school may have 12,500 points on a prospect, while your rival has 14,025. His decision date is coming up. Looks like you need to allocate more points to this prospect if you want to snag him!

2. For users who want a more robust recruiting experience, a brand-new recruiting system will be in place for this game. Here there will be a recruiting budget. The size of your budget will depend on your school’s financial situation, how good your job security is, etc. That budget can be spent on scouting players and in-home visits with recruits.

Once you’ve scouted players & created a board, you can call players & schedule in home visits, but be careful. Visiting recruits who live further away will eat into your budget a little more. And each week you will have an allotted amount of time available to spend calling recruits. During a call or visit, you will talk to the prospect via an RPG-like dialogue tree. During these conversations you can find out what that prospect likes, what he dislikes and what he doesn’t really care about. Are academics important? What about your coaching staff’s reputation? Your recent success? Facilities? The schemes you run? Proximity to home? Early playing time? By gauging their interest on these topics, you can pitch your school appropriately throughout the conversation. You can schedule a longer call where you will be able to answer more questions and make more pitches, but then you will have less allotted time to spend on other recruits.  

When the time comes, you can schedule an official visit with the recruit. You can tailor what the prospect does during a visit based on their interests. Perhaps one would rather take a tour of downtown while another would rather tour the academic resources. At the end of the official visit, a recruit will give you a short pop-up paragraph recapping how the visit went. If you scheduled his visit appropriately, he’ll give you great feedback & perhaps commit on the spot. If he’s interested in the social life & you sent him to tour the academic facilities, he’ll tell you he didn’t have the greatest time. If he’s super into facilities & you sent him on a tour of your facilities, but your facilities are crap he’ll tell you he’s seen better, etc.

Each week, when visiting the recruiting page you can view your standing with a prospect, schedule visits & make calls with your allotted time for that week. On each prospect’s profile you will be able to see your scouting report on him & see where you stand. He will either be Very Cold, Cold, Neutral, Mildly Interested, Interested and Very Interested. Once you become Very Cold prospects will no longer accept calls or visits from you. Prospects will also post a Top 20 toward the beginning of the recruiting cycle and gradually shrink it into a Top 15, Top 10, Top 5 and Final 2 as the cycle goes on. If they have announced a commitment date, that will also be displayed on their profile so make sure to get your visits in & prioritize calls accordingly! You will receive a notification when a prospect on your board becomes Very Cold, announces a new Top Schools list or commits, either to you or another school.

On other tabs on the recruiting page you can view your remaining budget, view a scholarship distribution chart & team needs by position.

Postseason

By default, the Dynasty Mode post-season will be a 4-team playoff with 35 generic bowls. You will be able to expand the playoff to 8, 16, 32 & even up to 64 teams if you want a crazy March Madness style tournament for football. It’s a video game. Player safety isn’t an issue here! You can adjust the settings to allow for the top-ranked teams to make the playoff or to have conference champions automatically qualify.

Players will also be able to set how many bowls are played & even be able to create Custom Bowls by creating the bowl’s name, selecting the stadium, selecting a date & uploading image files for the bowl’s logo. This can be used to re-create existing bowls, but also to create any ridiculous bowl game you want, such as the Scrubbing Bubbles Toilet Bowl. You will also have the ability to create conference alignments for your larger, more prestigious bowls. Doing this also allows you to create “Power” conferences whose members have larger recruiting budgets and better seedings for whatever post-season you select. 

Perhaps you want to abandon the playoff altogether & return to a BCS style system, although obviously called something different. And if you’re really nostalgic, you can revert to the pre-BCS days of the national champion being voted on after the bowls. Here you are not guaranteed a #1 vs. #2 matchup as conference-bowl alignments may not allow for it. This means you run the risk of a split national title as the generic coaches’ poll & writer’s polls may not agree.

Online Modes

Players will be able to play exhibition games against others online using any of the generic teams available on the base game or any custom teams they have created or downloaded.

An online dynasty mode similar to NCAA Football 14’s mode of the same name will also be available. Friends can compete throughout several seasons using any of the generic teams available on the base game or any custom teams they have created or downloaded.

Tournament Mode allows you to submit your custom team into a 4, 8, 16, 32 or 64 team tournament with friends or matched players online. However, you must be available for all the slotted times for each round or you will forfeit the game. From time to time, official tournament events hosted by the developer may become available.

Features to Consider in Future Installments

Because so much of this proposed game is customizable and able to be updated by the community yearly, annual installments of this franchise are not wise. However, a hungry market exists for a college football video game & one this robust would certainly find a sizable enough audience to make development of this series a worthwhile endeavor for a developer. A new installment once every 2-3 years that includes new features as well as updated graphics, mechanics and physics would be much more realistic.

Therefore, here's a list of new features to consider in future installments. Because creating this proposed game from scratch will already take a considerable amount of time and resources, these features are better left on the backburner for now.

Assistant Coaches

Hire, fire, promote & poach up to 9 assistants in Dynasty Mode with the inclusion of assistants. As head coach, a salary pool will be available for you to spend on assistant coaches and how you divvy that money between them is up to you. Pay an assistant too little and he may leave for another job. Pay one too much and other coaches may find their paychecks too small and you’ll soon find them poached away. 

Assistants affect the overall performance of their position group. A top-shelf RB coach may add stats such as +4 carrying, +3 pass blocking, +2 trucking to your position group whereas a mediocre coach may only add +1 carrying, +1 pass blocking, +2 trucking, etc. Certain assistants also may have specific scheme preferences as well. An RB coach used to an option system may add more points to stats such as trucking, but contribute nothing to pass blocking, etc. so fit is also something to consider.

Assistants will also assist in recruiting. You can assign assistants as lead recruiters for each prospect on your board up to a set maximum amount per coach. They will each have unique connections to certain parts of the country, so assign them accordingly. If you just want to recruit the south, hire assistants who all have connections there. If you want to recruit nationally, hire accordingly.

Assistants will continue to grow as they gain experience. Your mediocre QB coach may become a great one if your quarterbacks do well throughout your dynasty. That also means they will become more likely to be poached & will demand a higher salary. Pay them that salary and you risk upsetting another coach. But don’t worry. Keep winning and your assistant salary pool will gradually increase.

Athletic Director Mode

Basically, Dynasty Mode with a little more management involved. In this mode, players will still play the games and manage their team as usual but will have the added step of also assuming the AD chair.

The AD has an annual budget to manage & must decide how to allocate resources. Beyond overseeing the football program, you will be given notifications on how the other sports programs are doing. Being a football game, obviously your first priority is the football program, but if other major programs like basketball or baseball begin to decline, fans will start calling for your head. To continue overseeing the football program, you must use a reasonable amount of your budget to maintain the other programs. This includes allocating money to hire better coaches, set recruiting budgets and upgrade facilities for other sports. You can also increase your assistant salary pool for football, upgrade the weight room or build a new stadium, but doing so may take too much money from other programs, causing them to decline.

Increase your budget by setting ticket prices to as much as you think the market can hold, creating winning programs across the board, keeping boosters happy & voting on conference revenue agreements. Moving to a new conference may also improve your budget. As athletic director, you even have the ability to greenlight payment of players. This gives assistant coaches a significant boost to their recruiting stats but get too carried away and you run the risk of being caught and fired.

Community Hub for Online Mode

Players can create a custom athlete and freely roam with other players online in an open hub-world set in a generic university’s player facilities. Here you can find other players to face off with in an online match, sign up for tournaments, compete in various mini-games, show off your avatar's swag & interact via chat & emotes. 

Mini-games include weight lifting mini-games in the weight room or games such as darts and pool in the player’s lounge. Go to the practice field to challenge someone to drills or more arcade-style mini-games such as the tug of war or bowling mini-games featured in older NCAA football video games.

Competing in these mini-games as well as winning online matches will increase your player's “Rep.” Increasing your Rep allows you to unlock new swag and apparel for your avatar. Some items may be exclusively unlocked by winning tournaments.

And if absolutely necessary to sustain the profitability of the franchise, these items can be available as micro-transactions.

Custom Rules

Want to make a field goal worth 4 points and touchdowns worth 9? Go ahead. How about a touchback that sets the ball on the 2? Not sure why you would, but you do you. Here you can move PATs back to the 20 yard line, give teams 5 downs and make first downs 15 yards. Maybe holding is now a 30 yard penalty. Sure, why not? Hell, let’s make the field 150 yards long.

Maybe there’s always been that one rule in football that’s never made sense to you. Well now you can tweak it. Maybe you just prefer requiring 2 feet in bounds for a catch. Or maybe you just love chaos and want to make the game as nonsensical as possible. No judgement here.

Other Versions of Football

While we’re at it, why not make playing 8-man football possible? Above I suggested making this game customizable enough to allow for people to re-create their high school teams. Well what if you’re a kid who lives in small town Wyoming and plays on your school’s 8-man team? Don’t worry. I haven’t forgotten you. Or maybe you love Canadian football with their weird extra long fields & goal posts smack dab in the middle of the freakishly deep endzone. Sounds like fun!

How about taking the game back to its rugby roots and outlawing the forward pass?

Leatherhead Mode

If you really want to play football the old-school way, Leatherhead Mode will include more uniform customizations to allow for leather helmets, those extra baggy pants and the long sleeve sweaters they wore instead of jerseys. Once again, video games are 100% concussion free!

Additions to the stadium builder would allow for the creation of more old-school stadiums that are filled in with fans wearing 1920s-1940s attire. Gone are the modern video boards and sound systems. Leatherhead Mode removes the modern commentary and replaces the modern broadcast display with a more old-timey looking hub that includes the score, down and distance and time remaining.

Re-create the glorious ivy-league rivalries of the past! Let the 4 Horsemen of the Apocalypse from Notre Dame ride again! Experience a time when Minnesota was dominant! All possible in Leatherhead Mode.

Even More Customization

·       Create a Fan: Customize the facial features, hair, gender, skin tone and attire of a fan who will sometimes appear during crowd shots in the middle of the game. Create as many as you want and the game will shuffle through them during the “broadcast.”
·       Create a Mascot: Custom build your team’s mascot who will appear on the sidelines. Try to recreate a real mascot or create your own unique monstrosity.
·       Custom Music: Upload music files and set them to play during specific points. Play “Start Me Up” by the Rolling Stones before kickoff or Darude’s “Sandstorm” after a turnover. Maybe play “Jump Around” before the 4th quarter in your “totally not Camp Randall Stadium” stadium. Or for that authentic college experience, upload your team’s fight song and set it to play after a touchdown. Or maybe upload an audio file of a college band’s drumline to rumble in the background between plays. Add as many songs as you want for each category so the game can randomly shuffle. All audio would be distorted to sound like it's coming from the PA system in the stadium. 

Why This, or At Least Some of This, May Soon Be a Reality!

IMV Gaming, a company founded 2 or 3 years ago on the dream of returning college football video games, is attempting to make a game similar to the Basic Premise at the beginning of this article. So far it’s called Gridiron Champions but unfortunately most of their work so far has been in silence and they have only revealed a few details. We currently have no idea how far along they are, if they are capable of making a game with good enough graphics and production value or when a possible release date may be. There’s no reason why a major developer like 2K Sports couldn’t create this game and maybe they will once this model proves viable by a company such as IMV Gaming or indie developers.  

To read the few details IMV Gaming has released on their project, visit their website here.

The rest of this article is from my own imagination. I wrote this proposal to show people that a college football video game can still be done and to create buzz for one. Not only is there potential to create a great college football video game again, but there’s potential to create one better than we’ve ever seen before. Not being licensed by the NCAA doesn’t have to be a limitation. In fact it can be tremendous advantage as it creates the potential for more innovation, especially along the lines of team-building customization options. I mean no officially licensed NCAA game would ever allow you to skirt the rules and pay players at your own risk. 

When there’s a willing & active community with the right tools, not only can we re-create the college football we know and love in a video game, but we can create so much more as well.

If you don’t think this is possible or that the community would be willing to re-create all these teams, uniforms and stadiums, then check out this mod of Madden 19 that will soon be available for players on the PC to download for free. This is a mod, meaning this is a completely community driven effort. EA Sports did not create these assets. A mod means they simply opened up the game’s code and let others mess around with it as they pleased. It’s not perfect and certainly doesn’t replace a genuine college football game, but if this much can be accomplished within a game designed to be an NFL game, imagine what could be done with a game engineered to be a college football video game with all the customization tools built in for you and others to create with?


No EA Sports licensed college football video game would ever give you the ability to customize the college football post-season like this proposed game. No EA Sports game would ever allow you to re-create FCS teams like this or create stadiums with as much detail as proposed. But give the tools to a community of fans who deeply love college football and you’ll be amazed by what can be created.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BREAKTHROUGH: After Decades of 'N is for Knowledge,' World's Scientists Announce Creation of 2nd Nebraska Joke

After over four decades of milking the exact same joke about Nebraska football, the world's top scientists in every major field of research have come together to announce the creation of a 2nd joke. The original joke simply proclaims the 'N' on the side of Nebraska's football helmet stands for 'Knowledge.' They announced this breakthrough was the culmination of 10 years of collaborative research and over $250 billion spent. "Normally we'd spend that kind of time and resources on medical advances, technological breakthroughs, more efficient methods of engineering and manufacturing, but this joke had just gotten so stale. We eventually came to the conclusion that the best possible service we could do for society was to help them out of this rut," world-renowned quantum theorist Alain Aspect said. "I mean, come on! The joke doesn't even make sense. By the very structure of the joke, the joke teller is the one insisting the N stands for knowle...

To Break Nebraska Football Curse, Frank Solich to Sacrifice 'Lil Red at Halftime of Fordham Game

Lincoln, NE - After finding yet another Rock Bottom last week at Illinois, Nebraska football finds itself growing increasingly desperate to break the almost 2 decade curse that has befallen the program. The University of Nebraska-Lincoln announced this week that former Nebraska head coach Frank Solich would be returning to Memorial Stadium to perform a blood sacrifice of 'Lil Red while dressed as the original fan favorite "Blonde Herbie" during halftime of the Fordham game.  "We thank 'Lil Red and the unfortunate student scheduled to play him this Saturday for their long service to this university," said new UNL Athletic Director Trev Alberts in a statement released on Friday. "But these are desperate times and 'Lil Red was always kind of stupid anyway." The source of the curse remains unknown, but its existence has long centered around 3 popular fan theories: 1. The introduction of 'Lil Red as a mascot 2. The retirement of "Blonde Her...

$5.8M in Brick Wall Related Damages Reported in Nebraska after Scott Frost Releases Hype Video

Lincoln, NE - The state of Nebraska is reeling Friday morning from devastation and destruction caused by a hype video released Thursday afternoon by Nebraska football head coach Scott Frost on Twitter, sending thousands of fans across the state sprinting straight through the nearest brick wall, severely threatening the structural integrity of countless buildings. pic.twitter.com/2BR8slArsW — Scott Frost (@coach_frost) June 20, 2019 "WHO YOU ARE SOME OF THE TIME IS WHO YOU ARE ALL OF THE TIME," screamed Hastings resident Derick Bachmeier as he plowed through the exterior wall of the local Russ' Market and straight into the produce section. Even residents as far as the Sand Hills found themselves caught up in the hype as Randy Grove, 64, drove over 45 minutes to find a brick wall to his liking with the specific intention of sprinting straight through it. "I mean sure there were some cavity brick walls nearby, as well as dry wall, wood paneling and all ...